- One new review determined that highly engineered consumables may be just as habit-forming as cigarettes.
- The study authors observed that these foods are designed to boost reward and speed up the delivery of reinforcing ingredients.
- The “addictive” quality of these foods implies they promote uncontrollable eating and interfere with appetite regulation.
- The review authors propose that ultraprocessed foods could be governed by regulations akin to those for cigarettes.
Right now, there is no one universal description of ultraprocessed foods. Some people classify them as foods that include components you would not find in a personal cupboard, for instance emulsifiers and additives.
A lot of dietitians rely on the NOVA system to identify UPFs. This refers to foods that contain “combinations of components, primarily of manufacturing origin, often produced by a set of industrial techniques and methods.”
One new paper featured in The Millbank Quarterly proposed that UPFs may be just as habit-forming as tobacco products.
“I concur with these findings, as UPFs are deliberately designed to be incredibly tempting to the majority of people,” stated a bariatric surgeon independent from the research.
A study from 2023 suggests that more than 73% of the food supply in the US are highly processed.
“Cigarettes and ultraprocessed foods are not just whole foods but carefully designed consumable products created purposely to optimize biological and psychological reward and habitual overuse,” explained the new study’s authors.
Are UPFs Habit-Forming?
The review synthesized insights from addiction, historical health policy, and dietary science in order to highlight sensory and structural features that increase the rewarding nature of both tobacco and UPFs.
“Not everyone is ‘hooked’ to such products, but for a sizable group, they trigger typical habit-forming behaviors: strong cravings, loss of control, and continued use despite negative health effects,” commented a heart health nutrition expert.
“These products are deliberately engineered with processed carbohydrates, added fats, salt, and taste additives to maximize reward and repeat consumption, and the industry employs persuasive advertising strategies, particularly aimed at children,” she added.
Scientists examined five key areas:
- rapid absorption
- pleasure-based design, or designing foods to be extremely pleasurable
- dose optimization
- widespread availability
- misleading changes, or “wellness branding”
It was observed that, like tobacco, UPFs are fine-tuned to provide the right dose of sweetness.
“Refined carbohydrates stimulate dopamine production via the vagus nerve, while lipids achieve this through intestinal lipid sensing,” the researchers explained.
“… UPFs with high levels of processed carbs and added fats are among the most potently rewarding substances in the contemporary food supply. Notably this processed carb and fat combination is virtually absent in nature.”
The way such products rapidly deliver “pleasure-inducing” chemicals to the mind renders them potentially addictive, similarly to cigarettes.
The paper stated that while cigarettes are designed to deliver nicotine quickly, ultraprocessed foods are formulated to rapidly digest and absorb, as they typically have minimal dietary fiber. This makes it easier for the system to process lipids and carbohydrates more quickly.
Authors also note that UPFs provide intentional intense tastes that fade quickly and mouthfeels that melt in your mouth. This all helps to trigger more dopamine and encourages individuals to consume additional amounts.
‘Wellness Branding’ in Cigarettes, UPFs
According to the review, both the cigarette and processed food industries have historically employed a strategy called “health washing.”
This refers to when goods are marketed and reformulated to create an illusion of reduced harm while preserving the core of their properties.
This tactic in the cigarette sector gained traction in the mid-20th century with the introduction of filter tips on smokes.
These were sold as protective innovations that would trap tar and particles before they reached the respiratory system. The truth is, these tips provide minimal significant protection.
However, people often adapted by taking bigger puffs or smoking more frequently, which negated any decrease in toxin exposure.
The food industry has adopted a comparable approach. It employs labels like “low fat” or “sugar-free” to promote ultraprocessed foods.
Yet, these foods still contain the very highly reinforcing formulations. The issue is that these changes offer a superficial impression of wellness while the product’s habit-forming nature and metabolic harms remain intact.
Should Ultraprocessed Foods Be Regulated?
The authors stated at the conclusion of their review that nourishment and smoking products are fundamentally different.
Nevertheless, they cautioned that certain ultraprocessed foods function like engineered consumables rather than real nourishment. They proposed that public health policy should reflect this distinction.
“Tobacco offers a warning, and tobacco control offers a source of potential,” the authors stated.
Because of policies, smoking rates in the United States have fallen and have “altered public perception of smoking and eroded trust in the sector.”
“It is my opinion greater awareness about the harmful effects of ultra-processed foods is crucial to reduce public intake and enhance population wellness. The strategies employed to reduce cigarette use have been successful and may be a helpful model for ultra-processed foods as well,” commented one expert.
“I don’t think UPFs should be controlled exactly as tobacco, but they certainly deserve more robust, tobacco-inspired measures: marketing restrictions, obvious packaging warnings, tighter rules on health claims, and restrictions in schools or medical facilities,” noted another nutrition professional.
The researchers pointed out to people that lightly altered and whole foods have sustained human health for thousands of years.